Blog Home
Sales Coaching
August 31, 2023
Nishit Asnani
If you've been juggling between cold calling and email prospecting strategies, this blog post is for you. Dive deep into recent statistics, and efficiency studies, and unravel how to optimize your outreach strategy. Wake up, grab a cuppa, and let's tune in!

Roll up your sleeves, put on your headset, and let’s take a walk down this two-lane sales highway named Cold Calling and Email Prospecting. Yes! One of the most debated topics since the invention of the telephone and the @ symbol. Here, we put the 'talky' against the 'typey' and get serious about sales efficiency. So, let's break the ice (literally with cold calling, shall we?

The Cold Hard Truth about Cold Calling

Here’s something to warm you up - did you know about 20 years ago, it took an average of 3.68 cold call attempts to reach a prospect? Fast forward to today, it takes around 18 attempts, often making you feel like you’re dialing their number more frequently than your own mother's!

"Wait, what?" you say, a tad bit appalled. Well, my friend, welcome to the reality of cold calling.

Cold calling, as many brave warriors would tell you, is akin to exploring undiscovered lands with just a compass and blind gut — shooting in the dark and hoping you hit gold. The truth is, it’s a numbers game where your palm-moistening persistence pays off...just not always. According to stats, the success rate of cold calling is around a surprising 1-3%. Ouch, that's enough to freeze anyone’s enthusiasm, right?

But before we throw the telephone out the window, let’s face it, there's no denying that exhilarating feeling when your endless jabber finally strikes a chord, and you land that said hot lead. Victory! Plus, nowadays it's not about the novelty of the rotary phone, but about smart and strategic calling, backed by prep and research.

Ready to switch gears and check out if emails are saving the day? Grab the popcorn! No spoiler alerts, I promise.

Email Prospecting – A Silver Bullet for Sales Efficiency?

No more tongue-tied situations, or arguments with the office fern over your sales pitch. Email prospecting, ladies and gentlemen, lets your keyboard do the 'talky’ part. Backspace is your new best buddy and typos are your only fears. Sounds like crossing the sales 'Sea of Tranquility’, doesn’t it?

But let's shed some light on the truth before we start penning sonnets about email prospecting. According to MailChimp, the average open rate for emails is roughly 21.33%, and the click-through rate is about 2.62%. Hmm… makes you feel like you're shooting emails into a black hole, huh?

On the flip side, the VAST cyber universe enables you to swing at hundreds, thousands, or millions of prospects without causing chaos in your monthly telephone bill. You can track the opens, clicks, responses, disseminate targeted information, segment your audience, and if you play your cards right, you can even automate follow-ups.

Suddenly, that black hole doesn’t seem so terrible now, does it?

Comparative Analysis: Cold Calling vs. Email Prospecting

Reaching Your Target

First things first, cold calling is the 'Door-to-Door Salesman' of the 21st century. Yes, it's intimidating to rub shoulders with voicemails and apprehensive gatekeepers, but let's face it, it gets you in front of your prospects instantly. Ring ring… here's your pitch!

On the other hand, Emails are a bit like carefully crafted paper planes. Fold it right (read: killer subject lines), aim properly and it could land straight on your prospect's desk (inbox), attracting their eyeball through a pile of 'to-be-read-later’ correspondence.

Cold Hard Numbers

In a contest of pure numbers, Email prospecting does seem like Usain Bolt to Cold calling's tortoise. Data from indicates that an average sales rep makes around 52 calls daily, while a Salesforc study found that reps can send a staggering 500 emails per day. Impressive, isn't it?

But do remember, in the end, it's not just the number of arrows shot but the number of bulls-eyes hit.

Industry-specific Results

Here’s a little nugget of wisdom. It sounds like one-size-fits-all in this sales clothing store but truth be told, your industry does play a critical role in deciding the cold calling vs email prospecting winner. For example, industries with a complex product offering often find greater success in the immediacy and personal touch of cold calling. On the other hand, industries that cater to millennial or Gen Z audiences might find more success with Email prospecting.

Phew! Who thought 'talking or typing’ could get this complicated? But worry not, we're not leaving you high and dry. It's time to build an optimized outreach strategy, tailored perfectly to your audience.

Optimizing Your Outreach Strategy: A Cocktail of Success

Understand your audience

The Golden Rule of sales: The customer is not a target but a human being – often with a shorter attention span than a goldfish. So, do your homework. Do they prefer the personal touch of a call or are they email junkies who can't live without poking at their smartphones every 2 seconds?

Sure, I'm generalizing, but the point is, understanding your audience's preferences is paramount to your prospecting strategy. So grab that magnifying glass, put on your detective cap, and start investigating Sherlock!

Know your industry

The buzz around office water-coolers does offer nuggets of industry wisdom from time to time. Your industry could be leaning towards certain norms and trends that could tip the balance for cold calling or email prospecting. B2B companies with long-decision making processes may prefer the personal interaction of a call, while B2C or tech-savvy markets might enjoy the convenience of an email with plenty of clickable CTAs.

Aim for specific goals

Now here's a cheery thought: Throw out everything you thought you knew about your audience and industry because here the king of the hill is what you want to achieve. Yes, you read that right. You might want to alert major news networks because 'SELF-CENTERED' just took a positive spin.

Looking to spread awareness, nurture some leads, or close jumbo deals? The platforms offer different strengths, so choose wisely. Cold calls are often better for direct sales or high-ticket items while emails excel in lead nurturing and aligning with longer sales cycles.

Closing Deals from the Comfort of Your Pajamas - The Sybill Way!

Let’s make a pact. From here on out, we’re going to nix the term ‘cold’ calling because our AI assistant Sybill sure knows how to turn up the heat on those leads.

If you’ve ever dreamed of closing deals while lounging in your favorite PJs, sipping on your morning coffee, and petsitting your neighbor’s naughty cat, Sybill just made it come true!

This close-it-in-your-PJs, 'robot-assistant-that-runs-on-coffee' (metaphorically of course, its electricity bill is on us), auto populates your CRM fields based on call and email data in each opportunity.

From transcribing sales conversations, creating call summaries, drafting follow-up emails, to guiding you in closing more deals, Sybill goes the whole nine yards. It's truly an AI coach and assistant that works around the clock so you can close more deals while, let's say, practicing your victory dance!

Wrapping Up – The Path Forward

Whether it's dancing on eggshells with cold calling or walking in the park with email prospecting, the secret lies in tailoring your strategies to your business. It’s not about bidding adieu to one medium just because it feels like you're battling against strong gusts of wind. It's about buckling up, donning your best sales suit, and leveraging what each has to offer - all while Sybill sits coolly by your side, sipping on metaphorical iced tea, ironing out the kinks, and closing deals.

But remember, too much of either strategy, cold calling or email prospecting, can be like overdosing on Halloween candies - exciting at first, sickening later. Strike a balance and blend them both into your sales mix; it’s a cocktail everyone would love.

Thanks for reading! You can
for more insights!
Table of Contents

Magic Summaries are accurate and absurdly human-like

Save 5+ hours/week with automatic meeting notes that you can reference while following up and enter into your system of record. The magic summary includes the meeting outcome, next steps, conversation starters, areas of interest, pain points, and much more.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.